I have now done extensive tests on converting a single film from VOB to various formats and tested that they play via dlna (Twonky on Zyxel NAS) and usb direct. I then tested each fast forward and fast reverse up to x32 and observed the smoothness or otherwise, and the pause, play and stop. Not scientific but it may be useful.
MKV very poor jerkiness all speeds, pause/stop locks up via usb.
MKV slightly better via NAS, inconsistent.
AVI (MSMPEGV3) Perfect in every sense, via both.
MP4 (H264) as above but more jerky in rewind, via both.
TS (MPEG-2)slightly jerky both ways, via usb
TS (MPEG-2) very jerky both ways, only x4 fwd, no bkwd, via NAS
WMV very jerky, via both.
AVI (DIVX) no play via NAS, very poor via USB
MPEG2 via NAS play only no fast either way.
M2TS via USB not even listed, via NAS play only no fast either way
DV not listed either way.
[EDIT]
M4V (MP4) oddly seems slightly more jerky than MP4 though they ought to be the same??
MKV seems to be very bad so it seems the winner is MSMPEGV3 AVI which may be Microsoft MP4.
I do not know much about codecs and container formats, just observations on my setup HDR1000S 2TB with WD My Passport USB powered HDD into Humax USB socket. Hope it may give a start to some more serious study by somebody who knows more (almost anybody). If anybody wants to tell me that what I have written does not make sense regarding formats, please go ahead.
| Sun 12 Oct 2014 10:30:59
#2 |