I simply cannot fathom why people have all these problems with PVRs - it's just beyond my experience. We own the 1000s the 2000T and the Panasonic HWT 120 and all are what I refer to as 'set and forget' appliances.
Do they record when I want them too - yes.
Do they fail to record programmes - an absolute rarity usually down to the broadcaster.
Do I need a comfort blanket in the guise of tiny little icons - no.
What else is there to say? Perhaps people tinker when they shouldn't is the only thing I can think of.